This is a gritty, powerful book that teachers and parents could use to launch a number of discussions. Its a dictionary of the odd words found on film sets, for instance, a gobo is an object used to hide or block a light, 77 but its also used in theater. With kristen stewart, elizabeth perkins, richard hagerman, allison siko. In the movie, there is much less narration, and you hear melindas thoughts less than you do in the book. Melinda talks a lot more in the movie than in the book. It is ultimately as story of social acceptance and self acceptance with very clear messages to get across to. But that said, this book might be even better for those of us who do not work in the movies and just like them, because movie speak will make watching movies more fun. Although melinda doesnt know it, her choice of a poster of maya angelou to cover her own reflection in her janitors closet is an appropriate one. Between the book and movie speak, there are many differences between the two.
Text to text a passage from the novel is paired with an oped essay about a 16yearold woman who was assaulted by a classmate. Compare and contrast the movie speak to the book speak. Speak the film was produced independently and released in 2004. Lena difference number one one of the biggest differences i noticed was that at the end of the book melinda tells mr. The symbol of poster of maya angelou in speak from. He is the main antagonist of the book, and spends much of the narrative harassing melinda in various read full character analysis melindas mother.
Setting is absolutely an important element in the novel speak, as the different settings tell readers a lot about melindas state of mind one setting that is particularly revealing is mr. Overworked and distracted, melindas mother is aware that her daughter has suddenly. Her best friend, rachel bruin, has turned against her with all other of melindas fellow students looking away. Melindas only friend is heather, a new student, who tries to get melinda involved in her schemes to gain popularity. Speak premiered at the sundance film festival in 2004 as part of the. Freeman about what had happened during the school year and what had caused it, but at the end of the movie she. Will melinda ever tell someone, or will she keep it all a secret that will haunt her forever. What are three significant settings in speak and why are.
Shes riding the bus to her first day of high school. Speak is a 2004 american independent comingofage teen drama film based on the awardwinning 1999 novel of the same name by laurie halse anderson. Speak drama usa full movie in english with kristen stewart. She speaks for many a disenfranchised teenager while demonstrating the importance of speaking up for oneself. One difference is that in the movie, melinda meets heather on the bus. Jul 21, 2017 laurie halse andersons youngadult novel speak is rich with symbolism. Speak tells the story of melinda sordino, a ninth grader at merryweather high school in syracuse, new york. Anderson uses symbolism to illustrate melindas struggle and her eventual emotional growth as she begins to move. Oct 25, 2017 melinda sordinos freshman year of high school is not starting off the way she wanted. A famous african american writer, angelou writes eloquently about her own rape in the memoir i know why the caged bird sings. But if you really wanna find out the similarities and differences between the book and the movie, then you have to read and watch them. My students cant get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof. It includes a video of anderson reading a poem compiled from letters readers have sent her about the book and a 2minute movie trailer. I also love the fact that there is no hollywood trim on this movie, it is just a story and thats what makes it so good.
Feb 04, 2012 speak the movie part 7 of 10 duration. In laurie halse andersons powerful novel, an utterly believable heroine with a bitterly ironic voice delivers a blow to the hypocritical world of high school. The drama teacher who is an extra in the movie welcomes the students to try to. After a blurred trauma over the summer, melinda enters high school a selective mute. This is important, because the poster is very symbolic towards melinda. In the book speak, by laurie halse anderson, protagonist melinda sordino enters her freshman year of high school with a dark secret. After reading the book speak by laure halse anderson and then watching the movie speak, i see that there are many differences between the book and the movie.
Due to her trauma and inability to tell anyone about what happened, melinda spirals into a dark depression. Speak was a 1999 national book award finalist for young peoples literature. Differences between the movie and book speak answers. They all think shes a squealer because she called the cops. There is a time to be quiet and a time to speak out, and on the issue of sexual assault, a young woman needs to find the courage to raise her voice and ask for help. Also the parts about the party which i wont spoil for you are much more graphic in the movie than in the book. The critically acclaimed, awardwinning, modern classic speak is now a stunning graphic novel. Oct 23, 2009 between the book and movie speak, there are many differences between the two. I have seven new note books, a skirt i hate, and a stomachache. Melinda, a high school freshman, is the protagonist in laurie halse andersons speak. They are really sad, but yet really good and funny. Not often i get to say a movie is better than a book, but here we are. They are a great company to do business with and have a fantastic process for people who want to get their thoughts and ideas into a book. Groucho helps a camera operator, when the actor goes from sitting to crouching, in groucho style, so the close up isnt on the actors crotch.
Anderson visited the set during filiming and appears in one scene as a lunchlady serving potatos. Speak 2004 with elizabeth perkins, dick hagerman, kristen stewart movie. In the movie, melinda never hangs up the poster of maya angelou in her closet, like she does in the book. Speak is a film directed by jessica sharzer and is based on the novel written by laurie halse anderson. What is melindas biggest motivation for talking about the rape. What is her biggest motivation for not talking about it. One moment from the movie that was not in the novel is when andy evans rapes melinda in his jeep instead of the woods. It stars kristen stewart as melinda sordino, a high school freshman who practically stops talking after a senior student rapes her. Speak movie to book comparison there were many differences between the story in speak the movie and speak the novel. The emotions come across so much better on film since a lot of the story is inner monologue. The school scenes for the movie were shot at eastmoor academy on the east side. Accurate descriptions of the minutiae of high school will appeal to any teen who has felt like an outsider, and when melinda is finally able to speak, readers will rejoice in her triumphs.
Oct 26, 2009 speak movie to book comparison there were many differences between the story in speak the movie and speak the novel. In the book speak, by laurie halse anderson, melinda sordino is forced into the worst year of her life. Thrasher kristen stewart and hot gf stella maxwell let their abs speak for themselves. One of the differences in the movie was when heather met melinda. In the book, the school changed the mascot from trojans to devils to tigers then the hornets. Struggling with school, friends, and family, she tells the dark tale of her experiences, and why she has chosen not to speak.
In the movie, the school changed the mascot from trojans to hornets then the falcons. Kristen stewart stands against gendered dress codes, t. Every industry has its own lingo and the film industry has quite the colorful and historic one. Film production occured over a period of only 21 days in columbus, ohio. Kristen stewart speaking french is the cutest duration. Riveting and compassionately written, it is emotional and inspirational. Speak, published in 1999, is a young adult novel by laurie halse anderson that tells the story of high school freshman melinda sordino. Some of these differences affect the meaning of the movie. Their actions speak volumes even if their vocabulary is limited. The assault is depicted in a closeup of the anguished face of the attacked high school girl. A popular and handsome upperclassman, andy evans raped melinda at a party the summer before speak begins. The entire school feels like a minefield to her, and it seems. The timeline below shows where the symbol poster of maya angelou appears in speak.
Kristen stewart is a teenager traumatized into silence after a summer party ends in a police raid that leaves her ostracized by her friends but unable to explain her actions. Awardwinning short filmmaker jessica sharzer makes her feature debut with the teen drama speak, based on the youngadult novel by laurie halse anderson. In the book speak, by laurie halse anderson, melinda sordino is forced into. This is the underlying message of speak and the message laurie halse. What are the similarities between the book and the movie.
The symbol of poster of maya angelou in speak from litcharts. Her old friends wont talk to her, much less sit with her on the bus. The film is told through melindas eyes and is wrought with her sardonic humor and blunt honesty. Jan 09, 2015 speak 2004 with elizabeth perkins, dick hagerman, kristen stewart movie. The summer before starting high school, she was raped by a senior student, andy evans. August before her freshman year, melinda and her closest friends attend a party with seniors and beer. The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance. Book summary over the summer, she and her friends went to a party and melinda ended up calling the police, causing her friends and everyone at the party to socially reject her.
Does melinda change as a narrator from the first day of school, when the novel begins, to the last day of school, when it ends. Speak is a novel about empowerment and it is a book that every teen, especially teen girls, should read. Melinda sordinos freshman year of high school is not starting off the way she wanted. Speak characters from litcharts the creators of sparknotes.
John hawkins, business consultant and author of expect greatness. Speak study guide contains a biography of laurie halse anderson, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full. Maya angelou was also raped, and didnt speak afterwards. At the party, melinda feels uncomfortable and out of place. This simply constructed movie has a powerful storyline that had me drawn in from the first five minutes. Parents need to know that speak, a showtime 2004 movie based on a novel of the same name by laurie halse anderson, is an intense study of the aftermath of a sexual assault by a high school boy at a party where there was underage drinking.
Speak as a movie and book is a wellillustrated movie on sexual assault and the aftermath effect on a high school girl. Jan 21, 2020 speak is a novel about empowerment and it is a book that every teen, especially teen girls, should read. Oct 22, 1999 in laurie halse andersons powerful novel, an utterly believable heroine with a bitterly ironic voice delivers a blow to the hypocritical world of high school. Speak it to book is the expert with this kind of problem. Parents with teen children will find this movie helpful to fully understand what it feels like for a girl to suffer pains, anger, depression, and trauma associated with rape and other sexual violence against the girl child. Throughout the year, melinda imagines the poster as an empowering force, such as when it urges her to tell rachel the. Speak is an absolutely touching story about a girl who has been hurt but is unable to talk to people about it.
Melinda wishes she could tell rachel, especially rachel, her secret. The poster represents how melinda was unable to speak about her rape and how trapped she was. Some of these characters are the strong silent type who choose to speak only when it is completely necessary. Others are maybe unable or unwilling to speak for one reason or another. Sweeney and steve zahn costar in this drama based on the awardwinning novel by laurie halse anderson. Speak by laurie halse anderson meet your next favorite book. This book is a great reference for someone breaking into the movies and, because one probably cant memorize the full plate of strange terms in a single reading, good to keep around so that when you are on a set, you can do a quick look up. The main difference though, is that the book really emphasizes when melinda chooses not to speak. It is ultimately as story of social acceptance and self acceptance with very clear messages to get across to the reader. After accidentally busting an end of summer party due to an unnamed incident, melinda is ostracized by her peers because she will not say why she called the police. She gulps down a couple beers before walking outside for some fresh air. Speak tells the story of melinda sordino, a high school student who stops speaking after she is raped by a classmate at a party.
954 1475 692 476 759 1109 81 961 1215 1522 1322 207 750 1438 343 757 312 690 1434 920 829 1067 423 927 229 776 671 352 706 661 789 1025 1293 1434